Site icon Leadership Freak

Solution Saturday: Dealing with Someone who Second Guesses Everything I do

Dear Dan,

Over a year ago I took a new position. We have been enjoying great success with record results. Recently the person I replaced took a job that I have to work directly with. They have decision making responsibilities for the group.

From the moment they came back, they have been second guessing everything I do. This has happened in both large group settings and also directly to their boss, who then talked to my boss.

I feel trapped and have been second guessing everything I do. Its starting to affect my team.

Any suggestions on what to do without stepping on toes?

Second Guessed

Dear Second Guessed,

At the end of this reply, you will find some suggestions for dealing with backstabbers, but first I want to focus on you. Before you read further, I accept the idea that I could be completely off base.

I wonder if the issue is lack of decisiveness on your part? Perhaps this person was given the position that has decision making responsibility because you lack confidence in this area.

Learning to navigate situations where you’re second guessed is an important step on the leadership journey.

Your concern about stepping on toes may reflect a healthy concern for the feelings of others. On the other hand, it may reflect an unwillingness to take action when there’s emotional tension. I’m leaning to the later idea.

You write that you feel trapped. Feeling trapped suggests a focus on things you can’t change. We all feel it from time to time. Frankly, there are situations at work where we don’t have much control. The question is, “What is within your control?”

Can’t control:

  1. Emotions. It’s wrong to think you can prevent dark emotions. Buried emotions eventually manifest themselves.
  2. People. We influence people, but ultimately people make their own choices. Manipulators use unethical methods of influence. They tell lies to invite people to engage in self-defeating behaviors.
  3. Past events. History never changes. We do.

Can control:

  1. Responses to negative emotion. What will you do with the negative emotions that are connected with your antagonist?
    • Ruminate on them night and day or focus on something else?
    • Develop a plan to deal with this the next time it happens.
    • Ask yourself, “What can I do?”
    • Discuss this with several unbiased experienced outsiders. (My response should not be considered a fulfillment of this option. My ideas are inadequate because I don’t know enough about your situation.)
  2. Attitudes when things seem to go badly. What do the following words suggest?
    • Humility. Perhaps this situation is an opportunity to expand your leadership skills by learning how to navigate being second guessed.
    • Candor. How might you give voice to your concerns in a way that reflects concern for the team you lead and the organization as a whole? How might you say something that serves the best interest of you antagonist?
    • Toughness. Is this an opportunity to shift through your values and determine where you are willing to take a stand, even if it feels dangerous?
    • Transparency. How might you bring this situation to light in a way that serves the best interest of others? How might you give voice to what’s going on in your world?
    • Focus. How might you discover behaviors that move the agenda forward? Distraction destroys effectiveness.
    • Gratitude. Where might you find and express gratitude, even in small ways? Gratitude is freeing. You mention that you’re having great success. Celebrate, even as you press into the future.

Please forgive me if my focus on you is off base. Let’s assume your antagonist is a skillful backstabber.

5 suggestions for dealing with backstabbers:

Find the grain of truth. Backstabbers appear to express concern while causing harm to their victims. It’s likely that there’s a grain of truth in their concern. Otherwise, no one would listen. In your case, the grain of truth may be about your decision making skills.

Act decisively. Bring your second guesser into your decision making process. Before your next meeting, get their input. If they second guess you after giving input, call them out. “We discussed this yesterday and you were all in. What changed?”

Play office politics responsibly. Strengthen your relationships with higher ups.

Don’t confront a skillful backstabber. They will chew you up and spit you out. They’ve anticipated your moves and laid traps for you. I heard one skillful backstabber brag that she would cut you and you wouldn’t even know until the next day.

Brag about successes. The best way to brag about success is to publicly celebrate your team’s wins. Let others know about high performers on your team. Don’t brag about yourself. Brag about the people you lead.

What suggestions do you have for Second Guessed?

**I relax my 300 word limit on Solution Saturday.


Special Offer:

I enjoy reading, but I don’t always have time to read all the books that interest me. works for me.

One of my favorite features of is the 12 minute video that summarizes an entire book. Click here to check out a special offer for Leadership Freak readers. I hope you’ll watch the video summary.

Pour into your leadership if you expect amazing results from your leadership.

Watch for the special upgrade offer after you purchase your lifetime membership. Give to everyone in your organization for one year for an upgrade of only $49.00. (This upgrade is $49.00 per organization, not per employee.)  Click here to check out a special offer for Leadership Freak readers.

Don’t miss it. You receive a Lifetime Membership and 10 Annual Memberships to give to others for less than the cost on one Annual Membership. 

Exit mobile version